Best Isekai Anime & Manga Set In Otome Games

The simple isekai theme has evolved into an ever-expanding genre, and otome narratives are one of the newer additions to its expansive landscape. Otome games are dating sims, where the main character has various routes that end up with different love interests. Otome isekai anime and manga take up this premise but with a touch of isekai transmigration.

Most otome isekai narratives follow a similar pattern, with the protagonist being transmigrated into the body of either the game’s main character or the villainess. Since otome games follow a preset conclusion, these transmigrated characters are in a race against time to alter the game’s ending and save themselves from doom. With such a novel premise, otome isekai anime and manga have become the next big thing within the isekai landscape.

Updated September 4, 2024 by Ahmed Rehan Nasir:Otome anime and manga have become a staple within the isekai genre, as the versatility of this setting gives way to all manner of novel themes and narratives. The otome or dating sim premise has come a long way since its inception, with newer anime and manga branching out to themes that either subvert expectations or exclude the usual villainess trope associated with the otome theme.

While some stick to the basics, others turn the theme on its head for a truly one-of-a-kind premise. This list has been updated for fans of this subgenre who have exhausted their otome libraries with a few more exciting entries to check out.

12 I’m In Love With The Villainess

Anime-Planet Rating: 3.77/5

Rei is an avid fan of the dating sim “Revolution,” but instead of focusing on the game’s male love interests, Rei turns towards the romantic rival and villainess of the story – Claire Francois. Burnt out and overwhelmed, Rei peacefully passes away one night, but as she opens her eyes once more, the golden-haired villainess stands before her.

Realizing that she has been reincarnated into her favorite otome game, Rei jumps at the opportunity to profess her undying love for the villainess. I’m in Love With the Villainess stands out among the otome isekai landscape with its novel take, and the anime’s Girls Love theme further adds nuance to the narrative.

11 I’m The Villainess, So I’m Taming The Final Boss

Anime-Planet Rating: 3.81/5

After regaining her memories, Aileen Lauren d’Autriche realizes that she has been transmigrated into an otome RPG. Knowing that her character is destined to be slayed by Claude, the Demon Lord, Aileen begins to take a few countermeasures to alter her fate.

Instead of staying away from Claude, Aileen tries to tame the lord of demons with her seductive charm. I’m the Villainess, So I’m Taming the Final Boss features an amusing take on the isekai otome premise with Aileen and Claude’s intriguing romance.

10 Trapped In A Dating Sim: The World Of Otome Games Is Tough For Mobs

Anime-Planet Rating: 3.84/5

Most otome isekai narratives tend to feature the standard transmigrated villainess premise, but Trapped in a Dating Sim: The World of Otome Games is Tough for Mobs takes a slightly different approach. After being blackmailed to play an otome game, the series’ protagonist finds himself reincarnated in the very same game as a mob character.

Being a mob character named Leon Fou Bartfort, the odds are heavily stacked against the protagonist, and the only way for him to survive is by using his knowledge of the game to beat the system. The anime throws in all sorts of absurdities, with mecha robots and duels also making their way into the premise.

9 Villainess Level 99: I May Be The Hidden Boss But I’m Not The Demon Lord

Anime-Planet Rating: 3.93/5

After being reincarnated in the otome RPG “Light Magic and the Hero,” Yumiella finds herself as the game’s final boss. Despite having the role of a villainess, Yumiella decides to lay low to live a peaceful life in the game, yet she unknowingly overachieves to Level 99, far above the Level 10 cap.

Suspicions rise as Yumiella almost gets mistaken for the Demon Lord. However, her impressive level is enough on its own to cause several deviations in the game’s narrative. True to its namesake, Villainess Level 99: I May Be the Hidden Boss but I’m Not the Demon Lord follows Yumiella’s plight as her attempts to evade suspicions of being the boss constantly fail.

8 The Villainess Wants to Marry a Commoner!!

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.0/5

The otome theme has come a long way, and The Villainess Wants to Marry a Commoner!! is a testament to the versatility and novelty of the otome villainess landscape. While the manga keeps the usual romance storyline, it subverts the theme by pairing the villainess with a mere commoner who runs the game’s gacha store.

While The Villainess Wants to Marry a Commoner!! takes on many of the theme’s formulaic tropes, it still manages to present a somewhat novel spin with the villainess abandoning her otome role for a commoner. Despite the manga’s sound premise and decent setting, the art style can be a letdown for some. Moreover, the manga adaptation was, unfortunately, cut short, but fans can find a satisfying conclusion in the title’s light novels.

7 My Next Life As A Villainess: All Routes Lead To Doom

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.0/5

True to its namesake, My Next Life as a Villainess: All Routes Lead to Doom follows an otome villainess whose fate in the game is destined for doom. Regaining her past life’s memories, Catarina Claes realizes that every single route within the game leads to the villainess’ grave fate.

Now, Catarina must use her knowledge of the game to find a way to alter its ending. In the process of changing her fate, Catarina begins to thrive as the villainess, possibly changing the game’s preset conclusion once and for all.

6 Accomplishments of the Duke’s Daughter

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.10/5

While most isekai otome manga are set in the early phases of the game, Accomplishments of the Duke’s Daughter starts off right at the villainess’ final condemnation. With knowledge of the game’s events, Iris successfully convinces the Duke to grant her the role as the acting Lord of Armelia before she can be banished to the church forever.

With this premise, Accomplishments of the Duke’s Daughter forgoes the usual otome tropes for a narrative that focuses on nation-building, political intrigue, and resource management. The manga presents a rather mature take on the otome isekai theme, especially with its focus on philosophical elements.

5 I’ll Become A Villainess That Will Go Down In History: The More Of A Villainess I Become, The More The Prince Will Dote On Me

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.11

I’ll Become a Villainess That Will Go Down in History is another isekai villainess manga that subverts expectations with a main character that takes the role of being a villainess rather earnestly. Despite being a wicked villainess of an otome game, Alicia has one staunch admirer, a young girl who ends up transmigrating into her body after a freak accident.

While the title may present the manga as a more romance-centered narrative, I’ll Become a Villainess That Will Go Down in History explores all sorts of themes, with a focus on political intrigue and royal drama. With its novel premise, layered characters, and vivid art style, the manga certainly does its otome theme justice.

4 With One Day Left I’ll Break All The Destruction Flags: “Serves You Right!” RTA 24 Hour Record

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.16/5

Just before the day Alexandra is supposed to be condemned for her villainy, she regains her memories and realizes that she has been reincarnated into the game as the villainess in an otome game. With just 24 hours left to reroute the course of the game, Alexandra is in a race against time to right her wrongs.

Related

6 Best One-Shot Isekai Manga, Ranked

Despite being limited to one chapter, these one-shot isekai manga offer complete and compelling narratives perfect for a light and quick read.

With One Day Left I’ll Break All the Destruction Flags: “Serves You Right!” RTA 24 Hour Record is confined to only three volumes in total. Despite a shorter storyline, the manga feels complete and whole, without compromising on the narrative.

3 The Most Heretical Last Boss Queen: From Villainess To Savior

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.17/5

Pride is a cruel ruler in an otome game, but she eventually meets her doom after being slain by her own people. To take the fallen ruler’s place, a Japanese high school girl is transmigrated into the game as the new Pride.

With previous knowledge of the game, the new Pride is hell-bent on mending her predecessor’s wrongs. However, each time she tries to deviate from her villainous role, the game corrects itself. The Most Heretical Last Boss Queen: From Villainess to Savior takes on the isekai villainess premise but with a wholesome twist.

2 An Observation Log of My Fiancée Who Calls Herself a Villainess

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.24/5

An Observation Log of My Fiancée Who Calls Herself a Villainess is another otome manga that subverts expectations with a premise that keeps readers hooked till the very end. With the storyline presented from the perspective of both the villainess and the prince, readers get to experience the narrative unfolding from both sides.

The manga flips several tropes of the isekai villainess theme, whether through Bertia’s willingness to earnestly play the role of the villainess or Prince Cecil’s yandere archetype. Despite being a largely comedic manga, An Observation Log of My Fiancée Who Calls Herself a Villainess offers fleshed-out characters with nuanced goals, an element that lends the manga its appeal.

1 The One Within The Villainess

Anime-Planet Rating: 4.45/5

Isekai villainess manga tend to follow the tried-and-tested doomed protagonist trope, yet The One Within the Villainess pleasantly surprises its readers with its refreshing twist. When the transmigrated villainess fails to change course and ends up dying, the original villainess of the game reawakens, vowing to exact revenge on all those who took part in the transmigrated girl’s condemnation.

As a first within the otome isekai space, The One Within the Villainess’ narrative engages readers from the get-go. With Remilia hell-bent on revenge, the manga delves into all manner of dark themes, though these subtexts are exactly what cause the manga to stand out.